But what do you really think about Lead Safety?

CLASH reserves the right to edit for appropriateness, clarity, and decency.

Send your blog post to clevelandleadsafe@gmail.com

Where is the Lead Belt in the US

Where is lead in Cleveland?

Where is lead in your body?

CLASHers: Share your thoughts.

blog posts must be lead related, no personal attacks or electioneering

July 20, 2025 -- Stay in Touch Subscriber Michelle Finn writes

"I have been watching Clash and the responses by City Hall for the past 5 years. I find it frustrating that lead poisoning is not decreasing in children. I work as a realtor and property manager and was licensed for lead testing.

Vilifying the landlord is not working. So I have taken it upon myself to try to help one child at a time. Just today I found the probable cause and a solution to a poisoned 2 year old.

The rental was renovated with new LVP flooring, the interior surfaces painted and new carpeting installed within the past 5 months. The landlord I was assisting was willing to allow the tenant to break their lease with no penalty due to the lead blood test results. They honestly wanted to help this family. I offered to stop by and assess the condition of the unit, it would have passed a visual clearance. I used a lead quick test, a fluorescent reagent with a black light to quickly search for lead. The entry door, LVP flooring, and window sills were OK, but when I sprayed the carpet it displayed green specs under the black light. I assumed the carpet was old, due to how dirty it was. I found out later it was less than 6 months old. The problem was the family did not own a vacuum cleaner. The carpet had never been cleaned. The carpet tested positive in the entry of the parents bedroom. Dad is a landscaper and does not take off his shoes in the home. So I left the home and searched for a vacuum cleaner at Restore and Goodwill. I finally found an Oreck Canister Vacuum at Goodwill and ordered bags for it.

This is not the first time I have seen horribly dirty carpets at a rental, but it was the first time I thought to ask if they had a vacuum cleaner. Vacuums can cost a substantial amount of money, a rag and water to clean an LVP floor is practically free. So this Mom was attempting to keep the home clean, but ultimately failed because the family could not afford a vacuum.

So my practical action plan is to suggest that while attending community events or through emails and social media communications ask for donations of vacuum cleaners. Ask event visitors if there is carpet in their rentals/homes and ask if they have the proper tools to keep it clean and lead free. Do what I did, give them the vacuum to keep their child lead safe."

Are Advocates Losing the fight for Lead Safety?

By the time that Primary Election day in September, it will have been 61/2 years since the passage of Cleveland’s Lead Safe Certificate Plan which was, by the way, a watered down version of CLASH’s 2019 ballot initiative. Lets build on what we have learned over that period of time, to make a workable plan going forward. The risk that Cleveland faces is rejection of a “failed” program. Mayor Bibb's speedy pivot from Lead Clearance Testing to Lead Risk assessment is an example of policy adapting to new information, but the risk is that the public will grow tired of failed plans. That's why speedy resolution of the certificate backlog is so important. Voters need to see steady progress towards the goal of lead safety.

Maybe mass migration the solution to the lead belt?

January 11, 2024. Scientific American. Thousands of U.S. Cities Could Become Virtual Ghost Towns by 2100 The authors’ resulting projections indicated that around half of cities in the U.S., including Cleveland, Ohio, Buffalo, N.Y., and Pittsburgh, Pa., are likely to experience depopulation of 12 to 23 percent by 2100. Some of those cities, including Louisville, Ky., New Haven, Conn., and Syracuse, N.Y., are not currently showing declines but are likely to in the future, according to the findings. 'You might see a lot of growth in Texas right now, but if you had looked at Michigan 100 years ago, you probably would have thought that Detroit would be the largest city in the U.S. now.' Derrible says."
Unless we're all poisoned by algae. May 6, 2025. ProPublica. Millions of People Depend on the Great Lakes’ Water Supply. Trump Decimated the Lab Protecting It. "The Trump administration’s slashing of budgets and staff have Great Lakes scientists concerned that they have lost the ability to protect the public from toxic algal blooms, which can kill animals and sicken people."

CLASH says: It takes a comprehensive plan and a generational commitment

CLASHers are beginning to realize that there's no single answer and no quick "fix" to make Cleveland Lead Safe. As outlined on our Lead Safe Tool Kit there are 3 elements to a comprehensive strategy: Awareness, child testing and home testing. Each element must be in operation at the same time. Milwaukee is a classic example of what happens when the health department, the school system, and the community are working in isolation and fingerpointing. Here's a footnote from Milwaukee. March 20, 2025

From the March 11, 2025 Stay in Touch. What is your ideas on how to remove the BackLog at Building and Housing

SC writes: "...As a retired lead professional, i interviewed for a a job reviewing the certificates but I did not want FT employment. Karen said that due to the union i couldn't do a PT position. Here i was a well qualified candidate, wanting to come into CLE to help and then i was willing to accept a fairly low wage but they could not figure out how to repost it or talk to the union to allow me to work PT. So they do have candidates willing to come into CLE to assist them, but they don't seem willing/able to "think outside the box". I even offered to do be a contract person. crazy thing is that i could easily have 1-2 of my old co workers who are retiring to apply for these jobs, but none of us want FT employment."

In the February 23, 2025 Edition of "Stay in Touch" CLASH asked: What practices can the city adopt to speed implementation of the city's Lead Safe Certificate Law?

Here's your responses (all anonymous)

To make testing more effective and really prevent further child lead poisoning, Targeted Selection should be implemented. The City already has the data analytics to implement. Using the 2022 city wide building condition audit and GIS data, first select ALL homes described as in poor condition, collate this with children under 6 years old. Test all these home whether rentals or owner occupied. Next Target homes in Fair condition. My experience with testing makes me believe a large number of home being tested are occupied by only adults.
Hire retired lead risk assessors to clear out the backlog of cases at Building and Housing and put the new staff to work bringing more landlords into the system. Speed up the reimbursement of landlords who claim the grant from the Lead Safe Resource Center when their Certificate is approved.

The more EBLL cases you find, the better the outcome
CLASH told the funders: "There will be an increase in the number of children with elevated blood lead levels who live in CMHA properties. This seems counter intuitive for lead safe advocates to cite as an outcome, but the reality is that, for too long, children with elevated blood lead levels have not been identified at a time when they are most easily treated by removing the lead hazard and the stigma of treatment. One of the barriers to the accomplishment of lead safety is the fact that there are no good baseline statistics. For now we may have to rely on anecdotal reports to create a baseline for evaluations."

Requesting the PD for a correction

Friday December 13, 2024 Cleveland Lead Advocates for Safe Housing (CLASH) asks that the Plain Dealer/Cleveland.com make a correction to the article Lead safety advocates say Cleveland was unprepared when it pivoted to stricter rules for landlords in order to avoid any confusion between the Cleveland Lead Safe Advisory Board and our organization. Cleveland Lead Advocates for Safe Housing had no role in Thursday's meeting. Thanks for your immediate attention to this concern.

Saturday December 14, 2024. Sean McDonnell responds: Hi Spencer, I appreciate you reaching out. However, we don't mention CLASH in the story at all. So, there's no reference to CLASH to take out.

CLASH responds to Sean McDonnell and Elizabeth Sullivan: We have no objection to the content of the article, we'd like the title of the article to be changed. Many casual readers will only read the headline and jump to the conclusion that "Lead safety advocates say Cleveland was unprepared when it pivoted to stricter rules for landlords" is a reference to Cleveland Lead Advocates for Safe Housing. Who are the "Lead safety advocates" referenced in the headline? With all due respect, there were no "lead safety advocates" at the meeting. There were only Lead Safe Advisory Board members and city officials. We repeat our request for a correction. spencer

Sean responds: Spencer, I can understand where you're coming from, and I hope we can work together in the future as I cover lead issues in the city. However, I disagree that people will see that headline and assume its CLASH. More than one group of people can advocate for lead safety. And we don't write stories for people who only read headlines. I'll forward this onto my boss, Chris Quinn, so he's aware. He could always feel differently than I do.

Spencer says: thanks for forwarding this request to Mr. Quinn. That was going to be my next step. I know that you are new to this beat. On the other hand CLASH and its predecessor organization have been working this beat for 8 years. Let me know when you want a backgrounder. spencer for CLASH

Sean says: He replied, and decided we did not need a correction. I’m relatively free most of this next week, other than Tuesday.

Spencer to the public: Let's suppose that Signal Cleveland or Ideastream wrote "Not enough plain dealing at Lead Safe Advisory Board meeting"

Final thoughts

Spencer to Sean: Clearly we're beating a dead horse, but we'd like you to understand why we were concerned about the headline.

Cleveland lead safety advocates call on city hall for greater lead soil testing efforts Cleveland Lead Advocates for Safe Housing or CLASH applauds new lower lead soil safety standard, but wants more done to protect children

have a good holiday. spencer

Lead Remediation: Taxpayers clean up the mess left by the Richies via the Politicians

On December 4, 2024, the website NEO Trans-Ohio published news of a Brownfields grant to Clean up toxic wastes in downtown buildings. One of the grantees caught my eye. The Centennial Building in downtown Cleveland will receive $10 Million in tax payer dollars for asbestos removal, lead-based paint remediation, and soil gas mitigation (we're guessing that's leaded gas).

The article Centennial still alive, among Ohio Brownfield winners quotes the State Spokesperson: “Plans include adaptive reuse of the 1.4 million-square-foot property into workforce housing, offices, and retail spaces. The project will create 350 permanent jobs and support more than 3,200 construction jobs.”

In case the name Centennial Building doesn't ring a bell, the owner is Millennia Companies, which was recently debarred from receiving HUD funds last year and is under investigation by HUD and DOJ for it's financial operations. Millennia sues HUD after raid, accusations of misconduct.

Where is the environmental justice of Ohio Taxpayers remediating the properties of past oligarchs for future oligarchs? It almost seems like Robin Hood in reverse.

PS: "Creating 350 permanent jobs" probably means moving them from somewhere else in Ohio.

CLASH communications

Page updated

Google Sites

Report abuse